Debate & Autism
More

Decoding Assessment

The statistical vocabulary of your child's evaluation, in plain language

You do not need a statistics class to read your child's assessment report — but a report full of percentiles and standard scores is hard to question if the vocabulary is unfamiliar, and you are allowed to question it. Here is each term you will meet in an Autism assessment, and what it is actually telling you.

Behavioral Assessment

This measures social attention, restlessness, and social interaction. Concerns about aggressive or disruptive behaviors will show up on behavioral assessments. Special interests, literal interpretations, fixed conversational patterns, and social cue observation appear here as well.

A common evidence-based practice is the Functional Behavior Assessment, designed to find the root cause of why a behavior is happening. Much of that data is gathered on an A-B-C recording form: what happened before the behavior, what the behavior was, and what happened after.

A blank A-B-C recording form with columns for Antecedent, Behavior, and Consequence
An A-B-C recording form: what happened before, what the student did, and what followed.

Statistical Significance

Statistical significance asks whether the result of an assessment is accurate, or simply the result of random chance. A result can be called statistically significant if it occurs within a small range of standard deviation from the normal distribution.

A normal curve with the tail beyond an observed result shaded to show the p-value
The p-value, shaded, is the probability of an observed or more extreme result assuming the null hypothesis is true.

Standard Deviation

The distance between the average score and higher or lower scores.

Each assessment has a different standard deviation. For example, a difficult math test may have 15 students between the high score and the average score. A simpler science test may only have 3 students between the highest score and the average score. The math test has the greater deviation.

A normal curve marked with the percentage of scores falling within each standard deviation of the mean
About 68% of scores fall within one standard deviation of the mean, and about 95% within two.

Normal Distribution

This is a common distribution of outcomes from a test. Most of the class will score about the same. Some will score higher and some will score lower. Plot the scores on a graph and you get a bell shape — which is why the normal distribution is also called the bell curve.

Hand-drawn bell curve made of 100 children's faces, with standard scores from 40 to 160 along the base
The same distribution drawn as 100 children, with standard scores along the base.

Percentile

A percentile compares scores between individuals. A percentile rank of 50 means the score is as good as or better than 50 percent of others.

A normal distribution with the 90th percentile marked, 90 percent of the area to the left and 10 percent to the right
A normal distribution with the 90th percentile depicted.

Standard Score

The standard score compares how many questions an individual gets correct against how many other students get correct. The average is set at 100.

The standard score formula, and a scale of standard scores centred on 100 with a standard deviation of 15
Standard scores rescale raw performance; on the common scale shown, the mean is 100 and one standard deviation is 15.

Confidence Interval

Confidence interval is related to range. A statistician can say she is confident about the test results if the range of the results is small.

Confidence intervals are calculated using pre-defined formulas for each assessment. We can measure how often an assessment outputs the wrong result, and turn that into a numerical measure of confidence that it gave us the correct one.

A skilled assessor can confidently explain an assessment's confidence intervals in plain, understandable language. Ask them to.

A distribution with lower and upper confidence limits marked and 2.5 percent of outliers in each tail
A 95% confidence interval, with 2.5% of outliers falling beyond each limit.

Range

The difference between the largest score possible and the smallest score possible — and also between the smallest score received and the largest score received. When interpreting data from an assessment, a smaller range of scores generally means the data is more likely to reflect reality.

A number line marking the lowest and highest scores, with the distance between them labelled as the range
The range is the distance between the lowest and highest scores.

Criterion Assessments

This is a type of test that compares a student's performance to a state or class standard. The criterion is a desirable value decided by your community's relevant authority.

Two bar charts comparing criterion-referenced scoring against a fixed cut score with norm-referenced ranking against classmates
In a criterion-referenced test, the performance of other students does not affect a student's score.

Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM)

This is today's gold standard for medical diagnosis of neurodiverse expressions. It is a changing document, supported by the latest scientific and medical understandings of human cognition and behavior.

Cover of the DSM-5-TR, published by the American Psychiatric Association
DSM-5-TR (2022), American Psychiatric Association.

Putting the numbers together

Comprehensive collection

Data must be comprehensive because there is a risk of measurement error. This doesn't mean assessments are always wrong or shouldn't be done — they need to be done responsibly and as a community effort. A comprehensive report identifies strengths and weaknesses across the board and helps teachers develop the right plans. A lack of data can produce biases that lead to delays or ineffective treatment.

For case managers

Data can be overwhelming. Use underlining and highlighting to emphasize the main points. Terms like “percentile,” “standard deviation,” and “standard score” can confuse first-timers — grounding them in everyday analogies makes them clearer. Deficit-based language is also increasingly out of step with the current moment. One way to frame data is through a “relational” lens: a below-average standard score in communication need not be framed as a deficit, but as a sign that the community may be growing away from the test-taker — and the score marks the path back into relationship with that community.

Reading a report for EBPs

A report's academic achievement section can help identify potential reinforcers: does the student score highly in a subject because it's a personal interest, or because of how it's being taught? Exploring strengths tells you what's working so it can be copied elsewhere. The communication skills section shows the exact areas where support will help most.

Definitions drawn from Goldstein, S., & Ozonoff, S. (Eds.). (2018). Assessment of autism spectrum disorder (2nd ed.). Guilford Press.

Image credits